Who has to pay

A subcontractor usually signs with the main contractor, not with the developer or the employer. The main contractor is the party to the contract, and payment is claimed from it. In CC (Tel Aviv District) 5981-11-24 E. Elias v. Eretz Israel Museum Tel Aviv, decided in October 2026, the court treated the construction company that built the shell as a subcontractor, and the municipal corporation that managed the project as the main contractor. The construction company sued both the corporation and the State, which funded the project. Each defendant pointed at the other. The court ordered the main contractor, as the direct party to the contract with the claimant, to pay the approved invoices. As to the State, it held that its liability required a full evidentiary hearing and gave no judgment against it at that stage.

How quickly the main contractor must pay

The Fair Payment to Suppliers Law, 5777-2017 sets a payment deadline between private businesses as well. A subcontractor performing work in the course of its business is a "supplier", and a main contractor registered for VAT is a "business":

A customer that is a business and has contracted with a supplier for a transaction shall pay the supplier the consideration for the transaction no later than 45 days from the end of the month in which the invoice was delivered to it, unless the parties have expressly set a different payment date in the contract; however, a different payment date shall not be set unless this is required by the special nature of the engagement or it is not an exceptionally unfair date.

Section 3(g) of the Fair Payment to Suppliers Law, 5777-2017 (unofficial translation)

If the contract is silent, payment is therefore due no later than 45 days from the end of the month in which the invoice was delivered. A contract may set another date, but only expressly, and only where the special nature of the engagement requires it or the date is not exceptionally unfair. Under section 7, the Law may not be contracted out of except in the supplier's favour. It applies to contracts made on or after its commencement date.

The invoice itself matters. The Law lists the ways an invoice may be delivered, including personal delivery, registered mail with confirmation of delivery and an electronic message with confirmation of delivery. It is worth using a method that proves the delivery date. If the invoice lacks a material detail required by the contract, or was delivered before the material conditions for payment were met, the main contractor must return it and specify the defects, and the invoice is then treated as not delivered.

The Law also says what happens when an invoice is returned late. If it is returned after the review period, which for this kind of transaction is 23 business days from delivery, the main contractor must pay no later than 10 business days after the last payment date. The time until the subcontractor delivers a corrected invoice is not counted. In a contract between a business and a supplier the parties may agree otherwise, subject to the same test of special nature or no exceptional unfairness.

Late payment carries shekel interest and, after 30 days, late-payment charges. In an engagement between a business and a supplier, this addition applies only where the business had the upper hand in shaping the contract terms. The section adds that it does not detract from any other remedy the supplier has by law for late payment.

The "back-to-back" clause

Many contracts between a main contractor and a subcontractor provide that the main contractor will pay the subcontractor what it receives from the employer for the same work. This is a "back-to-back" clause. When the employer does not pay, the main contractor often argues that it does not have to pay either.

In LCA 3458/10 Tzevet Karka v. HaKodchim Shabbat, the Supreme Court, sitting as a single judge, refused leave to appeal to a main contractor that made this argument, and added that the application would fail on the merits too. The employer in that case was in liquidation, and the court wrote:

The purpose of a "back-to-back" clause in engagements between a contractor and a subcontractor is, as a rule, to prevent a situation in which the contractor is forced to pay the subcontractor for work that was not approved and not paid for by the employer because of factors connected with the subcontractor, such as work performed partially or defectively.

LCA 3458/10 Tzevet Karka v. HaKodchim Shabbat Ltd (5.9.2010), para. 11 (unofficial translation)

The court added that even if the main contractor had not been paid by the employer because of the liquidation, that did not cancel its liability to the subcontractor, since it had been found that the subcontractor did the work.

In the Elias case, the Tel Aviv District Court noted that this decision is not binding precedent, because it was given by a single judge. In another judgment the same court said it should be treated at least as guidance for the lower courts. Many trial courts have followed it. On that approach, where the subcontractor did the work properly and the employer did not pay for reasons unconnected with it, the main contractor is not released. Some courts have read such a clause as fixing the time of payment rather than as a condition of the right to be paid at all.

In the Netivim Darom case, decided in 2018, the Tel Aviv District Court applied that approach even to an express clause. The contract provided that the subcontractor "will not be entitled to receive any payment from Dori as long as Dori has not received the relevant payment from the employer and/or the developer" (Dori was the main contractor). The court held that to release the main contractor there must be "a kind of causal link" between the employer's non-payment and the subcontractor's conduct. It also held that the main contractor breached its heightened duty of good faith by failing to tell the subcontractor that its relations with the employer were deteriorating while continuing to order work from it. According to the court, that breach was enough on its own to make the main contractor liable, even if the clause had released it. It also held that even on the main contractor's reading, the main contractor had not pointed to specific works and invoices that were not approved or not paid.

That judgment was replaced by a settlement. On appeal, on the Supreme Court's recommendation, the parties agreed that the subcontractor would repay the main contractor ILS 1.3 million, and the agreement took the place of the judgment. The Supreme Court noted that it had not ruled on the question of principle.

Case law that gave the clause effect

There is also case law the other way. In Insolvency Case (Tel Aviv District) 1705-09 Y.G. Peretz v. Kidron, decided in 2011, the contract expressly made every payment to the subcontractor conditional on payment by the employer. The main contractor was under a stay of proceedings at the time. The court held that the contract must be read according to its wording, and that the clause allocates risk and operates precisely where non-payment is not due to the subcontractor's negligence. The subcontractor's application was dismissed.

In the Taladan case, also decided in 2018, the Tel Aviv District Court dealt with the same project and the same main contractor as in Netivim Darom and reached a different result. In its view, the Tzevet Karka decision had been given "a far-reaching interpretation", since it was confined to a case where the employer went into liquidation, and a court must be cautious with an express and clear clause. The subcontractor proved the debt, but the court held that it could collect only after the arbitral award between the main contractor and the employer, and subject to its outcome. The court added that even if the clause only fixes the time of payment, that time had not come while the arbitration was still running.

In a 2018 decision on an application to stay execution in Netivim Darom, Supreme Court Justice A. Baron remarked, obiter, that the question had not yet been discussed at length by the Supreme Court, "without detracting from the principle laid down in Tzevet Karka", and that the case law on it is conflicting. She gave Netivim Darom and Taladan as examples.

Where the clause is express and the non-payment may also be connected with the subcontractor's work, the subcontractor's position is weaker. In such a case the Tel Aviv District Court, in a 2024 interim decision, stayed the subcontractor's claim until the arbitration between the main contractor and the employer ended.

Drafting the clause

In Elias, in a partial judgment, the court summed up that the law does not invalidate such clauses outright, but they are to be read narrowly. To deny a subcontractor payment for work that has no defect, the contract terms must be "clear, sharp and unequivocal". A statement in the contract that the money came from the state budget was not enough. The court remarked that even a clear clause is not necessarily the end of the matter, since reliance on it must be in good faith, but it did not decide that point.

The picture, then, is not uniform. The wording of the clause and the reason the employer did not pay may decide whether the subcontractor is paid at once, only after the dispute with the employer is resolved, or not at all.

Retention money

Many contracts let the main contractor withhold a percentage of each invoice until the work is completed. In Elias the works were stopped for good, and the court ordered the main contractor to pay, in addition to the approved invoices, the retention money it had admitted. This is a partial judgment of a first-instance court and may be appealed.

Working without registration as a contractor

Section 14(a) of the Registration of Contractors for Engineering Construction Works Law, 5729-1969 provides that works whose financial scope or professional nature exceed the range set in regulations may be performed only by a registered contractor. Performing such works in breach of the Law is an offence.

In CA 195/84 Nahariya Municipality v. Yetach Yamin, decided in 1986, an unregistered contractor won a municipal tender and carried out clearing and surveying work, and the municipality cancelled the agreement. The Supreme Court held that the agreement was void and left the contractor only with restitution for the clearing and surveying, without compensation for idle equipment or lost profits. The justices differed on the reasoning. The decision was given in accordance with the judgment of Justice D. Levin, who treated registration as a condition precedent that was not fulfilled. Justice A. Goldberg treated the contract as illegal, and President Shamgar wrote that he agreed. That case concerned a direct engagement with a municipality and preparatory work only, not a subcontractor who completed construction work and is claiming its fee.

Section 31 of the Contracts (General Part) Law, 5733-1973 allows the court, where a contract is void for illegality under section 30 and if it considers it just, to order a party to perform its obligation where the other party has already performed its own. The Supreme Court has described this, in another context, as "an exceptional power, to be construed narrowly".

A subcontractor whose work requires registration should make sure it is registered in the right branch and classification before it starts work.

Practical steps

  • Read the payment clause before signing, especially any term that links payment to payment by the employer.
  • If the contract has a "back-to-back" clause, ask for it to apply only where the employer did not pay because of a defect in the subcontractor's work.
  • Keep the supervisor's approvals of invoices and of the work done. They show that non-payment has nothing to do with the quality of the work.
  • Deliver every invoice in a way that proves the delivery date.
  • Ask the main contractor in writing for information on the employer's payments for the works you performed.