When the developer is liable for a defect

Section 4 of the Sale (Apartments) Law, 5733-1973 sets out when the seller of an apartment, meaning the developer or contractor who sold it, has failed to meet its obligations. The starting point is the gap between the apartment delivered and what was promised. If the apartment or anything in it differs from the specification, an official standard or the building regulations, that is a "non-conformity". Alongside this, the Law divides the time after delivery into periods, each with a different burden of proof.

  • The inspection period begins when the apartment is placed at the buyer's disposal, and its length depends on the type of defect. If a non-conformity appears during it, the developer is liable unless it proves that the buyer's act or omission caused it.
  • The warranty period is three years from the end of the inspection period. The developer is liable for a non-conformity that appears during it if the buyer proves that it originates in the design, the work or the materials.
  • A fundamental non-conformity is a non-conformity in the parts of the building that bear and transfer loads to the ground, concerning its stability and safety. The developer is liable for it for 20 years from delivery, unless it proves that the buyer's act or omission caused it. Even after 20 years it is liable if the buyer proves that it originates in the design, the work or the materials.

The developer must also give the buyer maintenance and use instructions, and if it does not, it has failed to meet its obligations. For an apartment whose sale contract was made before Amendment 5 to the Law came into force in 2011, or in a building completed before then, an earlier version of the Law applies, including the inspection periods and some of the provisions described in this article.

How long the inspection period lasts

The schedule to the Law sets the inspection period by type of defect:

  • Defects in frames and joinery, including aluminium and plastic: two years.
  • Defects in interior flooring and cladding, including subsidence and wear: two years.
  • Failure in the function and durability of machinery and boilers: three years.
  • Defects in the development of the yard, such as paths, surfaces, fences and systems on the building's grounds: three years.
  • Failure of components of the thermal insulation systems: three years.
  • Failure of plumbing systems, including leaks: four years.
  • Failure of the building's waterproofing, including in walls, ceilings and roofs: four years.
  • Cracks wider than 1.5 mm in non-load-bearing elements: five years.
  • Detachment, peeling or crumbling of exterior cladding: seven years.
  • Any other non-conformity that is not fundamental: one year.

The one year is the general inspection period, and the case law often calls it the "inspection year".

How quickly the developer must be notified

Under section 4A, the buyer may rely on a non-conformity if the developer was notified in time. A defect that could have been discovered when the apartment was delivered must be notified within one year of delivery. A defect that could not have been discovered on a reasonable inspection at delivery must be notified within a reasonable time after it is discovered. The same rule applies to a fundamental non-conformity that could not have been discovered on a reasonable inspection at delivery.

It is best to notify in writing, with the date, a description of each defect and photographs, so that the notice can be proved if the matter reaches court.

The developer's right to repair

The Law prefers the defect to be repaired by the developer before the matter reaches court:

Where a non-conformity or a fundamental non-conformity capable of repair has been discovered, the buyer or sub-buyer must give the seller a fair opportunity to repair it, and the seller must repair it within a reasonable time.

Section 4B(a) of the Sale (Apartments) Law, 5733-1973 (unofficial translation)

The Supreme Court has described this as "a system of mutual obligations". The buyer must give the developer a fair opportunity to repair, and the developer must repair within a reasonable time. Under section 4B(b), the buyer may carry out the repair at the developer's expense in two situations: where the defect reappears after the developer has repaired it once or more within two years of the buyer's notice, and where the repair is urgent and the developer has not carried it out within a reasonable time of the notice.

And what if the developer had a chance to repair and did not? In CA 656/99 Bar Shira v. Meonot U'Binyan, decided in 2003, the Supreme Court held that if the buyer gave the developer a fair opportunity to repair before suing, no further opportunity can be required in the proceedings. In that case, where the court proceeded on the basis that the developer had neglected its duty to repair, the buyers were awarded full compensation so that they could carry out the repairs through another contractor.

When to sue

Under the case law, as a rule, a claim for construction defects is filed only after the inspection period has ended, and after the developer has had a fair opportunity to repair during it or shortly after it ends. This is not a rigid rule. If the buyer gave the developer a fair and genuine opportunity to repair, and the developer did not repair within a reasonable time or ignored the buyer's requests, the way to court may open even before the inspection period ends.

How long you have to sue: limitation

The inspection and warranty periods determine which defects the developer is liable for, but they do not postpone limitation. In LCA 830/06 Gelman v. Cohen Pituach-Dra'ad, decided in 2008, the Supreme Court held that the cause of action for defects that could have been discovered at delivery arises on the day the apartment is delivered. The seven-year limitation period runs from that day, regardless of the inspection period, the notice to the developer or the opportunity given to repair. In that case the buyers had notified the developer of the defects in time, and the claim for the visible defects was nevertheless dismissed as time-barred.

For hidden defects the court noted that the date may be different, under section 8 of the Prescription Law, which deals with facts unknown to the claimant. It also noted that new damage caused by the repair works themselves is a new cause of action. So you should not wait for a long inspection period to end before suing over a defect that was visible at delivery.

A buyer who did not let the developer repair

The case law had two approaches to what happens to a buyer who sued without giving the developer a chance to repair. Under one, the buyer loses the right to compensation for the defects; under the other, the compensation is only reduced. In LCA 18136-03-26 Amiran v. Shami Ashkeloni, decided in August 2026, the Supreme Court settled the question, unanimously, sitting as a panel of three.

In that case two buyers sued the developer less than a year after delivery, without giving it a fair opportunity to repair most of the defects. The Magistrates' Court awarded them compensation based on the developer's cost of repair. The District Court denied compensation for the defects, apart from one. The Supreme Court restored the Magistrates' Court judgment and held:

Failure to give the contractor a fair opportunity to repair a non-conformity, within the meaning of section 4B(a) of the Sale (Apartments) Law, does not in itself lead to a complete denial of the buyer's right to compensation for construction defects that have been proved. As a rule, the consequence of this omission on the buyer's part will be a reduction of the compensation to the appropriate extent. As a rule, such compensation should be set at the cost of repair that the seller of the apartment would have incurred had it carried out the necessary repair itself.

LCA 18136-03-26 Amiran v. Shami Ashkeloni Ltd (18.8.2026), para. 48 (unofficial translation)

The consequence is financial. In the court's words, such a buyer is not entitled to the cost of repair by an outside contractor, and so does not receive the contractor's profit and the extra costs involved in such a repair. In Amiran the gap between the two methods was 20%, according to the court-appointed expert, and the Supreme Court noted that the gap may be larger, depending on the circumstances.

The rule has two exceptions. Where the buyer acted in flagrant bad faith and deliberately frustrated the repair mechanism, a greater reduction may be considered and, in extreme cases, even a denial of compensation. The court noted that the case before it was not such a case. On the other hand, where the buyer was justified in refusing, for example a genuine crisis in the relationship and a deep loss of trust in the developer because of the nature of the defects or its earlier conduct, the buyer may receive full compensation. The court made clear that merely opportunistic behaviour is not enough for that.

Waivers as a condition of repair or delivery

Developers sometimes ask the buyer to sign a waiver of claims as a condition of carrying out repairs or delivering the apartment. Section 7A(b) of the Law, in its current version, provides that a waiver of rights relating to a non-conformity, made a condition of carrying out repairs in the apartment or placing it at the buyer's disposal, is void. Section 7A(a) provides that the Law may not be contracted out of except in the buyer's favour.

Practical steps

  • Inspect the apartment thoroughly at delivery, and record every defect in the delivery protocol.
  • Remember that for a defect visible at delivery, the seven-year limitation period starts on the day of delivery.
  • Notify the developer in writing of each defect, with the date, a description and photographs. A defect visible at delivery must be notified within one year.
  • Let the developer come and repair, and record every visit, every repair and every refusal.
  • If the developer does not repair or ignores you, keep your requests. They may open the way to a claim even before the inspection period ends.
  • Before refusing a repair by the developer, consider whether there is real justification. A refusal without justification may cost part of the compensation.