What counts as defamation
The Prohibition of Defamation Law, 5725-1965 defines defamation as anything whose publication may, among other things, humiliate a person in the eyes of others or make them a target of hatred, contempt or ridicule, disgrace them for acts, conduct or traits attributed to them, or harm them in their position, business, occupation or profession. A "person" for this purpose includes a corporation, so a company can sue too.
A publication is read as a reasonable person would understand it. In CA (Haifa District) 29581-03-26 Nagar v. Hardon, decided in June 2026, the Haifa District Court, on appeal from a Magistrates' Court judgment, described "an objective test, made from the point of view of the reasonable person, examining the overall context and the circumstances". The court held in that case that "not every curse or insult will necessarily give rise to a defamation claim". Insults traded in a heated argument were held not to be defamatory, and the court said that it is not "charged with policing language". By contrast, messages accusing members of the municipal lifeguards' committee of financial irregularities were held to be defamatory.
What counts as publication online
Under section 2 of the Law, publication may be oral, written, printed, by drawing, by sound or by any other means. It is enough that the defamation was intended for someone other than the injured person and reached that person or anyone else apart from the injured person, or, if it is in writing, that the writing was likely to reach someone other than the injured person. In LCA 1239/19 Shaul v. Nidely Communications, decided in January 2020, the Supreme Court held that writing a post or status on a social network is a publication. It also ruled on actions that echo a post written by someone else:
A distinction should be drawn between the act of sharing and the marking of a like (or similar "feeling" marks), and it should be held that only the former amounts to publication within the meaning of the Prohibition of Defamation Law.
LCA 1239/19 Shaul v. Nidely Communications Ltd (8.1.2020), para. 43 (unofficial translation)
In the court's words, a share creates a kind of "copy" of the publication, displayed to the sharer's friends or followers. A like creates no such copy, even if the network's algorithm then shows the post to more users. As for a comment on a post, the court said the focus is on the content of the comment itself.
A message in a WhatsApp group
Under section 2(b), a written message likely to reach someone other than the injured person is a publication. A message in a WhatsApp group reaches every member of the group. In Nagar v. Hardon the messages were sent to the WhatsApp group of the Haifa municipal lifeguards, which, on the Magistrates' Court's assumption, had dozens of members. When dealing with the amount of compensation, the District Court said that the fact that the words were written in a group of the people concerned, the claimants' colleagues, "does not, in my view, blunt the sting of the injury, if anything the opposite".
In the same case another member of the group replied to one of the messages with the words "every word is solid". The Magistrates' Court held that the reply was a separate publication, since it was meant to confirm what the message said and give it extra weight. The defendants did not appeal, so the finding was not reviewed by the District Court. On that judgment, someone who endorses another person's offensive message in a group may be liable in their own right.
Whom to sue
Where an offensive post has been shared by many people, the Supreme Court held in Shaul that the default is to sue the original publisher first. Only the original publisher can remove the publication as a whole, while a sharer can delete only its own share. The exception is special circumstances, for example where the original publisher is anonymous or cannot be traced.
Suing only a sharer, or one sharer out of many with no real distinction between them, may raise suspicion about the claimant's motives. The claimant may explain the choice, for example because the sharer added offensive text of its own, is a public figure, or had a share that reached a wide audience. The court mentioned the option of striking out a claim that abuses court process, and said the power should be used "with extra caution". In that case itself the court did not decide whether the claim was selective.
When the publisher is anonymous
In LCA 4447/07 Mor v. Barak I.T.C., decided in 2010, the Supreme Court held by a majority that there is currently no procedural framework for an order unmasking an anonymous internet user, and that the courts should not create one. Where the wrong is also a criminal offence, a police complaint can be filed, and the investigation is a matter for the enforcement authorities.
The rule has been criticised. In CC (Haifa District) 9656-01-23 Zaltzman v. Meta, in 2024, the court wrote that the Mor rule "has been eroded over the years". It cited decisions in which courts ordered the social network to notify the user of the claim and let them object, and Magistrates' Court decisions that granted an order where there was a "main suspect". It also noted that Mor did not discuss disclosure under section 16 of the Protection of Privacy Law. Even so, Mor is "the prevailing rule". Several bills have been tabled to regulate the matter.
A person harmed by an anonymous publication should document it carefully. In Zaltzman the claim to disclose the profile details was struck out, among other reasons because the claimants did not set out the words published and did not attach the publication itself. The court recalled that in a defamation claim the words giving rise to the cause of action must be set out precisely, preferably quoted, and the publication attached to the statement of claim.
How much compensation
The Law allows compensation even where the injured person does not prove any damage:
In an action for a civil wrong under this Law, the court may order the defendant to pay the injured person compensation not exceeding 50,000 new shekels, without proof of damage.
Section 7A(b) of the Prohibition of Defamation Law, 5725-1965 (unofficial translation)
The amount in the Law is index-linked, so in practice it is higher than ILS 50,000. If it is proved that the defamation was published with intent to harm, the court may award up to double that amount, again without proof of damage. In Nagar v. Hardon the court recalled that this requires a "genuine" intent to harm. Alongside this route there is the ordinary route, in which the injured person proves the damage, pecuniary and non-pecuniary. The ordinary route has no ceiling. The Supreme Court has made clear that the two routes are alternatives, not cumulative.
Section 7A(d) provides that a person shall not receive compensation without proof of damage "for the same defamation" more than once. In LCA 2855/20 Plonit v. Ploni, decided in October 2022, the Supreme Court held that several publications can earn several separate awards. The court used several aids for this, among them the content of the publications and how similar they are, the time between them and, according to the majority, also the identity of the recipients. In that case, which concerned Facebook posts about a lecturer, three awards of ILS 65,000 each were made, ILS 195,000 in total.
In Nagar v. Hardon the District Court increased the compensation for the two committee members to ILS 27,000 and ILS 20,000, instead of the ILS 18,500 and ILS 13,500 awarded by the Magistrates' Court. It remarked that a large gap between the amount claimed, ILS 300,000 in that case, and the amount awarded may affect the award of costs.
Correction and apology
Section 9 of the Law allows the court to order publication of a correction or denial, or of the judgment, at the defendant's expense and in the place, to the extent and in the manner it decides. It does not mention an apology. In Nagar v. Hardon the Magistrates' Court ordered the defendants to publish an apology in the same WhatsApp group, and the defendants did not appeal.
On the other side, section 19(4) allows the court to take into account in the defendant's favour that it apologised, corrected or denied, provided the apology or correction was published "in the place, to the extent and in the manner in which the defamation was published, and was not qualified". An apology sent privately to the injured person, where the post was public, does not meet this condition.
The publisher's defences
Under section 14, it is a good defence that what was published was true and that there was a public interest in the publication. Both conditions are required. Section 15 protects a person who published in good faith in one of the circumstances it lists. These include a relationship with the person to whom the publication was addressed that imposed on the publisher a legal, moral or social duty to publish; protection of a legitimate personal interest; and an expression of opinion on the injured person's conduct in a public role or in connection with a matter of public interest.
Under section 16, a person who proves that they published in one of those circumstances and that the publication did not go beyond what was reasonable is presumed to have acted in good faith. The presumption is reversed, among other cases, where what was published was untrue, and the publisher either did not believe it was true or did not take reasonable steps before publishing to check whether it was true.
In Shaul the Supreme Court held that all the circumstances in section 15 may also apply to someone who shared a post. Where the original publication concerns a public issue, a moral or social duty to share information that has already been published "will be examined leniently". A person who shared a post but clearly distanced themselves from it in the accompanying post, or condemned it, may be protected by the defence for a publication made only to condemn or deny defamation published earlier. In that case the court did not need to apply the defences in practice, because the compensation had been set by a procedural agreement between the parties.
If you have been defamed
- Take screenshots of the publication at once, with the date, the publisher's name and where it was published. In a WhatsApp group, record the list of participants too.
- Keep the exact words. The statement of claim must set them out, preferably quoted.
- Find out who originally published the words before suing those who shared them.
- Consider demanding an apology and correction in the same place where the defamation was published.
If you have been sued
- Remove the publication and, if it was wrong, publish a correction or apology in the same place and manner, without qualifications.
- Keep the sources you relied on. They matter for the truth defence and the good-faith defence.
- If you shared someone else's post, check whether you distanced yourself from it in the share, and whether the claimant also sued the person who wrote it.