Seven years, and fifteen for land

Section 5 of Israel's Prescription Law, 5718-1958, sets the period within which a claim must be filed:

The period in which a claim on which no action has been filed becomes prescribed (the prescription period) is: (1) in matters other than land, seven years; (2) in land, fifteen years, and if registered in the land registry after settlement of title under the Land (Settlement of Title) Ordinance, twenty-five years.

Prescription Law, 5718-1958, section 5 (unofficial translation)

Most civil claims, such as a debt, a breach of contract or compensation for damage, are "other than land", so seven years apply. A claim concerning land itself is time-barred after fifteen years, or twenty-five years for land registered after settlement of title. Other statutes sometimes set different periods for particular claims, so it is worth checking whether a special rule applies.

Prescription is a defence, not the end of the right

Under section 2, if a time-barred claim is filed and the defendant pleads prescription, the court will not hear it, "but prescription alone does not extinguish the right itself". The Supreme Court has described Israeli prescription as procedural rather than substantive: the debt is not wiped out, but it can no longer be enforced by action if the defendant objects.

Three practical consequences follow. First, the defendant must raise prescription himself. Under section 3, if he does not plead it at the first opportunity after the action is filed, the court will not hear it. Second, under section 4, a claimant cannot plead prescription against a set-off or counterclaim that shares the subject of his own claim or arises from the same circumstances, if his own claim was not time-barred or the defendant did not plead prescription against it. Third, filing a claim in court stops prescription. A letter of demand, phone calls or negotiations do not stop the clock, unless the parties agreed on an extension in a separate written contract (see below).

If the claim was struck out or dismissed in a way that does not prevent it from being filed again, section 15 provides that the time during which it was pending is not counted, but the clock starts running again from the date of dismissal. Under section 16 the period will not end until at least a year after that date. The suspension applies only as against those who were parties to the first claim.

Half a year that does not count: the Swords of Iron amendment

Following the war, section 15A was added to the Law. For a claim not concerning land whose limitation period had not ended when the amendment took effect in January 2024, the period from 7 October 2023 to 6 April 2024 is not counted. A claim whose period ended between 7 October 2023 and the start of the amendment is treated as not yet time-barred, unless the court decides otherwise for special reasons. The section also applies to limitation periods set in other statutes, with the exceptions listed in it. Anyone counting seven years today needs to take this half year into account.

When the seven years start

Under section 6, the period begins "on the day on which the cause of action arose", meaning the day on which the claimant had all the facts needed to sue. For a debt this is usually the date payment was due. For other claims the date depends on the cause of action and the remedy sought, so it should be checked case by case.

Claims in tort have a special rule in section 89 of the Civil Wrongs Ordinance. Where the cause of action is an act or omission, time runs from the day it occurred, or if it continued, from the day it stopped. Where the cause of action includes damage, time runs from the day the damage occurred, and if it was not discovered that day, from the day it was discovered. In that last case, however, there is a limit: the action is barred unless filed within ten years of the damage occurring. In Civil Appeal 1254/99 Hameiri v. Hachsharat Hayishuv the Supreme Court described the result as two time barriers: seven years from discovery of the damage and ten years from its occurrence, whichever comes first.

The ten-year limit applies only to the damage element. Under the Hameiri rule, as later case law has described it, where other facts of the cause of action came to light late, such as the causal link between the act and the damage, section 8 of the Prescription Law applies to them, and it has no such ceiling.

When the claimant did not know about the claim

Section 8 of the Law postpones the start of the period in certain cases:

Where the facts constituting the cause of action were concealed from the claimant for reasons not dependent on him, which even with reasonable care he could not have prevented, the prescription period begins on the day those facts became known to the claimant.

Prescription Law, 5718-1958, section 8 (unofficial translation)

The section has two conditions. The facts were hidden from the claimant for reasons beyond his control, and even with reasonable care he could not have discovered them. Someone who had signs that should have prompted him to look into the matter, and did not, may find that time started running back then.

The section is about facts, not law. In Civil Appeal 3602/97 Income Tax Commission v. Shahar the Supreme Court held that section 8 does not allow the start of prescription to be postponed because the claimant did not know he had a right. A person who knew what happened, but not that he could sue, will not benefit from it.

Section 7 of the Law, as amended in 2015, adds a suspension for wrongful conduct by the defendant: prescription is suspended for as long as the claimant refrains from suing because the defendant, or someone acting for him, knowingly misled him, used force against him, threatened him or exploited his distress. "Misleading" for this purpose includes knowingly concealing one of the facts that make up the cause of action.

An acknowledgment or part payment restarts the clock

Under section 9, if the defendant acknowledged the claimant's right, in writing or before a court, the prescription period starts again from the day of the acknowledgment. This is so even if the acknowledgment was given after the period had already expired. Under the same section, an act that amounts to partial performance of the right, such as paying part of the debt, counts as an acknowledgment.

There is a proviso. An acknowledgment accompanied by a plea that the claim is already time-barred does not count. And the acknowledgment must be in writing or in court. An oral statement made outside court is not enough.

Minors, agreed periods and judgments

Minors. Under section 10, the time before the claimant turns 18 is not counted. A claim by someone injured as a minor therefore generally starts to run when he comes of age. For a claim over sexual assault of a minor, or abuse of a minor by a family member or a person responsible for the child, the time until age 28 is not counted (section 18A). The section also covers sexual assault of a young person under 21 in the circumstances it specifies.

Agreed periods. Under section 19, the parties may agree on a longer limitation period, and for claims not concerning land also on a shorter one, but not less than six months. The agreement must be made "in a separate written contract". In Civil Appeal 270/75 Ramad v. Westchester the Supreme Court held that such an agreement has no effect where it is merely woven into the main contract between the parties as one of its clauses. The separate contract may appear on the same sheet of paper, but it must be drawn up as a separate contract and signed separately.

Judgments. Judgments too can become time-barred. Under section 21, if twenty-five years have passed without the judgment creditor taking any step to enforce it, the debtor may plead prescription.

Practical steps

  • Note the date the cause of action arose: the payment date that was missed, the date of the event, or the date the damage was discovered. The seven years run from that date, and sometimes you need to add the Swords of Iron half year.
  • If you learned of the claim late, document when and how you learned the facts. A claimant relying on late discovery also has to show that he could not have discovered them earlier.
  • Do not rely on letters and negotiations. Without a claim being filed, a written acknowledgment, a part payment or an extension agreed in a separate written contract, the clock keeps running.
  • Check whether your contract contains a clause shortening the limitation period. An ordinary clause within the contract, not drawn up and signed as a separate contract, does not meet the statutory requirement.
  • If you are sued, plead prescription in your statement of defence. Under section 3, a plea not raised at the first opportunity will not be heard.