A business can sue. The real question is whether the reviewer has a defence
Israel's Prohibition of Defamation Law, 5725-1965, defines defamation to include anything whose publication may harm a person "in his business, occupation or profession". A "person" for this purpose includes a company, so the company that runs the business can bring the claim itself. A review describing the service as bad may fall within that definition.
In Koala Pet Supplies v. Duchan (Tel Aviv Magistrates' Court, civil claim 2834-01-20, July 2023), the court held that both a customer's Google reviews and his Facebook comments were defamatory. The case was decided at the next stage, on whether one of the statutory defences applied, and the burden of proving a defence lies on the person who published.
A consumer review is an opinion on a matter of public interest
Section 15 of the Law protects a person who published in good faith in one of the circumstances it lists. For a customer review, the relevant one is the expression of opinion in section 15(4), which covers publications that were:
an expression of opinion on the conduct of the injured party in a judicial, official or public capacity, in a public service or in connection with a matter of public interest, or on his character, past, actions or opinions insofar as they were revealed in that conduct.
Prohibition of Defamation Law, 5725-1965, section 15(4) (unofficial translation)
In Pogrebnoy v. Hamo (Nazareth District Court, civil appeal 5001-02-18, October 2018), the District Court heard an appeal by a customer whom the Magistrates' Court had ordered to pay a pizzeria ILS 15,000. Her pizza arrived soggy. She posted photos on her Facebook page, wrote that it was soaked in liquid "to an inedible level" and added the hashtag "yuck". The District Court held that consumer criticism is a matter in which the public has an interest within section 15(4):
Businesses that offer their wares to the consuming public expose themselves to criticism, including negative and sometimes harsh criticism, from that public. This public, which invests its money in buying a product or service, has every right to express its opinion of the product or service it bought.
Civil Appeal (Nazareth District) 5001-02-18 Pogrebnoy v. Hamo (31.10.2018), para. 13 (unofficial translation)
The appeal was allowed and the claim against the customer dismissed. In the same paragraph the court added that the freedom to criticise does not mean a right to unbridled abuse. Criticism of that kind, it said, tells consumers nothing about the product, and the business learns nothing from it about how to improve.
Opinion is protected. A statement of fact has to be proved
Section 15(4) protects opinion, not statements of fact (Civil Appeal 89/04 Nudelman v. Sharansky, para. 34). The words are read in context, and the line between the two is not always easy to draw. A statement of fact can be defended under section 14, the truth defence, but that requires proof of two things: that what was published was true, and that its publication was in the public interest.
The good-faith defence, by contrast, does not depend on the truth of what was said. The Supreme Court wrote in Further Civil Hearing 2121/12 Anonymous v. Dayan-Orbach (para. 43) that it will usually be relevant precisely where the publication is untrue or cannot, for one reason or another, be proved true. In Koala, the customer failed to prove that the grooming salon was wrong to say his dog's coat needed extra treatment, or that its prices were higher than other salons'. The truth defence failed, but the good-faith defence covered his Google reviews.
That defence has its limits too. Under section 16(b), a publication is presumed not to have been made in good faith if what was published was untrue and the publisher did not believe it, or took no reasonable steps before publishing to find out whether it was true. A reviewer who describes something that did not happen risks losing the defence.
One customer, two outcomes
In Koala, a customer and a dog-grooming salon fell out over a haircut that never took place. That day he posted a one-star Google review saying the owner had "shouted and tried to rip us off for 700 shekels". A few days later he added: "Lousy service. They hurt you and the dog to squeeze crazy prices out of you". On the day of the first review he also wrote three comments on the salon's business Facebook page: "lying thieves", "a garbage place" and "a disgusting place that treats its customers with contempt".
The court treated the two sets of posts differently. The Google reviews, it said, were factual criticism which, even if phrased somewhat bluntly, contained enough text to show the wider context. It rejected the argument that "they hurt you and the dog" accused the salon of physically harming animals, and read the words as criticism of the quality and price of the service. The good-faith defence applied to those reviews.
The Facebook comments, on the other hand, were abusive remarks lacking the element of consumer criticism. They told the public nothing about the service, and the business could learn nothing from them. The court also adopted a finding by another Magistrates' Court that calling a business a "liar" will usually go beyond legitimate consumer criticism. For the three comments it awarded ILS 5,000.
In both judgments the court separated criticism that tells readers something about the product or service from abuse that tells them nothing. A blunt word inside an account of what happened can still be legitimate criticism. Insults with no account at all are hard to defend. In Koala the court also noted that whether an insult is defamatory depends on context, and that not every tasteless remark is defamation.
How the court decides whether a review was reasonable
Under section 16(a), a defendant who proves that the publication was made in one of the circumstances listed in section 15, and did not exceed what was reasonable in those circumstances, is presumed to have acted in good faith. In Pogrebnoy the court cited the Supreme Court in Ben Gvir v. Dankner: the publisher's conduct before, during and after publication carries significant weight in assessing whether it was reasonable.
The court gave weight to the fact that the customer first complained to the pizzeria in a private message, with photos, and posted only after her complaint was brushed off. She shared the post with her friends rather than turning straight to the public at large, and she did not rant: in the court's words, "yuck" came nowhere near the line. She later took the post down, even though the owner and his friends had written harsh things about her. In Koala, too, the customer deleted his Facebook comments two days later, and the court took that into account in keeping the award low.
Reviews from people who were never customers
The broad protection is for genuine consumer criticism. In Koala the court distinguished it from criticism that only appears to come from a consumer but in fact does not.
The Drucker v. Eliasi case shows the difference. The owner of a food business posted a sharply worded comment on a divisive political affair on her private Facebook page. A musician with tens of thousands of followers urged them to visit her business page and give her "a single star". Many users posted harsh reviews of her food business, and she had to close the page. The Tel Aviv Magistrates' Court found that none of the reviewers had consumed her products, held that this was not legitimate consumer criticism and ordered them to pay compensation. It dismissed the claim against the musician, but the Tel Aviv District Court allowed the appeal and held him liable as an inciter under section 12 of the Civil Wrongs Ordinance, ordering him to pay ILS 25,000. The Supreme Court refused him leave to appeal (Leave for Civil Appeal 2030/22, August 2022, which describes the earlier judgments).
To hold someone liable for reviews written by others, his part in them must be proved. In Koala the salon argued that the customer's friends had posted negative reviews at his prompting, and that he himself had written more under fake accounts. The court rejected both claims: being Facebook friends does not prove incitement, and the salon did not call the reviewers to testify. The claim over 11 of the 16 posts failed for that reason.
What a business owner can do
- Record the review straight away: a screenshot showing the date, the writer's name and where it appeared. A statement of claim must set out the exact words.
- Assess the content against the case law. A review that describes an experience, even bluntly, may be protected. Insults with no description, a statement of fact the writer knows is false, or a wave of reviews from people who were never customers give much firmer grounds for a claim.
- If the reviewer is anonymous: under Leave for Civil Appeal 4447/07 Mor v. Barak ITC, there is currently no procedural framework for an order revealing an anonymous user's identity. The ruling has been criticised and eroded, and trial courts have made orders in some cases, for instance where there was a "main suspect". It remains the prevailing law, however, and a disclosure order should not be expected as a matter of course.
- Think about how much to claim. The Law allows compensation without proof of damage up to an index-linked ceiling, and double that where intent to harm is proved. In Koala the plaintiffs claimed ILS 300,000 and were awarded ILS 5,000. The court ordered the plaintiffs, the company and its owner, to pay the same amount towards the customer's legal fees, because they had forced him to mount a far more expensive defence than necessary. The two sums were set off against each other, so in the end the business received nothing.
Before you write a review
- Say what happened: what you ordered and what you actually got. With context, readers can see what the review is based on.
- Keep opinion and fact apart. Only state a fact if you can prove it.
- Leave out the insults. "Lying thieves" and "a garbage place" are exactly the comments that cost the customer in Koala.
- Complain to the business first. In Pogrebnoy the court gave weight to the private complaint that preceded the post.
- If you went too far, take it down or correct it. Under section 19(4), the court may take into account in the defendant's favour that he apologised, corrected the statement or took steps to stop its distribution. An apology or correction must be published in the same place, to the same extent and in the same way as the defamation, without qualification.