A foreign judgment is not an Israeli judgment

Section 2 of the Foreign Judgments Enforcement Law, 5718-1958 provides that no foreign judgment shall be enforced in Israel other than under that law. So a creditor holding a judgment from New York, Moscow or London cannot walk into the Execution Office, the state body that collects judgment debts in Israel, and open a file. An Israeli court must first declare the judgment enforceable.

Section 1 defines a foreign judgment as a judgment given by a court in a foreign state in a civil matter. The definition also includes a judgment ordering payment of compensation or damages to an injured party, even where it was not given in a civil matter. It therefore reaches further than it first appears. On its wording, it may also cover an order made in criminal proceedings to compensate the victim, although the courts have also expressed reservations on that point.

Only after the declaration does the judgment enter the ordinary collection process. Section 10 provides that a judgment declared enforceable has, for execution purposes, the status of an Israeli court judgment. The same section adds that an obligation in foreign currency is paid in shekels at the rate of exchange on the day of payment, although the debtor may also pay in the foreign currency itself. Where years pass between judgment and collection, the exchange rate can make a considerable difference to the amount in shekels.

The four conditions the applicant must prove

Section 3 sets out four conditions. The court may declare a foreign judgment enforceable if it finds that all of them are met:

  • The judgment was given in a state whose laws empowered its courts to give it.
  • The judgment is no longer subject to appeal.
  • The obligation in the judgment is enforceable under the laws governing enforcement of judgments in Israel, and its content does not conflict with public policy (the basic values of the Israeli state and society, including morality, justice and fairness).
  • The judgment is executory, meaning it can be enforced, in the state in which it was given.

The burden of proving the four conditions rests on the applicant. The grounds of opposition in section 6, by contrast, must be proved by the party resisting enforcement. That follows from the wording of the statute, and the Supreme Court confirmed it in CA 7251/20 Katziv v. ZAO Raiffeisenbank. On the second condition, finality, it pays to arrive with clear evidence that appeal routes in the state of judgment (the country where the judgment was given) have been exhausted, or that the time for appealing has passed. While the judgment remains open to appeal, the condition is not met.

Section 8 makes an exception for maintenance matters (family support payments). In such matters the court may, if it considers it justified in the circumstances of the case, enforce a temporary foreign judgment or an interim order (a temporary decision given pending the final ruling) even while they are still open to appeal, provided that they meet the other conditions of the law. This is an exception to the rule in section 3(2).

Public policy under the third condition does not routinely block enforcement. In CA 1268/07 Greenberg v. Bamira the Supreme Court held that enforcing punitive damages (damages meant to punish the wrongdoer, over and above compensation for the harm) awarded between private parties, in a civil matter with no governmental or public character, does not conflict with public policy. That is so even though in states such as the United States such damages are awarded in cases where they would not be awarded in Israel. The court did not treat the gap between legal systems as a ground for resisting enforcement.

Reciprocity, and why it is a smaller hurdle than it looks

Section 4(a) provides that a foreign judgment shall not be declared enforceable if it was given in a state whose laws do not provide for enforcement of Israeli court judgments. On its face this is a heavy requirement calling for proof of foreign law.

In practice it is lighter. In the same Greenberg case the court held that, since most states satisfy the reciprocity requirement, an applicant need not prove it where it is plainly satisfied. It also held that the burden on the point falls on the party opposing enforcement. A debtor who wants to rely on an absence of reciprocity must carry that burden, not merely raise the question.

Under section 4(b), the court may also enforce a foreign judgment where there is no reciprocity, if the Attorney General applies for it.

The five years that cannot be missed

The court shall not entertain an application to enforce a foreign judgment filed more than five years after the date of the judgment, unless a different period was agreed between Israel and the state in which the judgment was given, or the court finds special reasons justifying the delay.

Section 5, Foreign Judgments Enforcement Law, 5718-1958

The period runs from the date of the judgment, not from the day the creditor discovered that the debtor holds assets in Israel. A creditor who spends years trying to collect in the state of judgment may find that the period has run out. However, in CA 247/83 Hochman v. Raveh the Supreme Court held that a creditor cannot be expected to file enforcement applications in every country in the world. Not knowing where the judgment should be enforced, for example because the debtor moved to Israel only at a late stage, can therefore count as a special reason for the delay. That is a matter for the court’s discretion, so it is safer to file within the five years than to rely on the exception.

The law leaves two openings. The first is an agreement between Israel and the state where the judgment was given that sets a different period. That is an agreement between states, not between the parties to the case. The second is special reasons justifying the delay, which must be put before the court and grounded in facts rather than in general explanation.

What the other side can raise

Section 6(a) lists five grounds of opposition. The court will not declare a foreign judgment enforceable if one of the following is proved:

  • The judgment was obtained by fraud.
  • The opportunity given to the defendant to make his arguments and bring his evidence before judgment was, in the court's view, not reasonable.
  • The judgment was given by a court lacking jurisdiction under the rules of private international law applicable in Israel (the Israeli rules for disputes with a foreign element).
  • The judgment conflicts with another judgment given in the same matter between the same parties and still in force.
  • At the time the foreign action was filed, proceedings in the same matter between the same parties were pending before a court or tribunal in Israel.

The second ground has featured in several of the leading decisions in the field. In CA 1948/15 JSC VTB Bank v. Margolis the Supreme Court held that the question is whether, objectively, the defendant was given a reasonable opportunity to make his arguments and bring his evidence before the foreign court. The inquiry, it added, is conducted with care and with respect for the legal systems of other states. The bank’s appeal was allowed and the Russian judgments were declared enforceable, because the court papers had been sent to the address the debtor himself had given the bank in the guarantee agreements.

Under section 6(b), a debtor who appeared before the foreign court only to argue that it had no jurisdiction to hear the case is not treated as having submitted to its jurisdiction, that is, as having accepted its authority to decide the case. The same applies where the debtor appeared only to seek dismissal or a stay (a pause in the proceedings) so that the dispute could go to arbitration or to a court in another state, or to seek the release of property that had been seized or was liable to be seized, or to protect it. The debtor can therefore contest jurisdiction abroad without losing the point. Section 6(c) adds that arguing the merits, or taking part in the proceedings in any other way, does not change this, provided it was done before the foreign court gave its final decision on jurisdiction.

Separately, under section 7, a foreign judgment shall not be declared enforceable if enforcing it is liable to prejudice the sovereignty or security of Israel.

Which court, and what must be attached

The original text of the law reserved jurisdiction to the Jerusalem District Court. Section 9 was repealed by Amendment No. 2 of 1977, after the legislature concluded that there was no point in concentrating every enforcement case in a single court. Since then no special jurisdiction rules apply, and applications are heard under the ordinary rules. In LCA 7551/00 Fuchs v. Katzenellenbogen the Supreme Court held that where the foreign judgment orders the payment of money, subject-matter jurisdiction (which level of court hears the case) depends on the amount the judgment orders to be paid. A judgment for a sum within the jurisdiction of the Magistrates Court is therefore heard by the Magistrates Court. Where the value of the relief cannot be assessed in money, the application is heard by the District Court under its residual jurisdiction, meaning its power to hear any matter not assigned to another court.

The Civil Procedure Regulations (Foreign Judgments Enforcement), 5744-1984 set out the procedure. Regulation 353 requires the application to state the name and address of the court that gave the judgment and the date of the judgment. Regulation 354 requires an authenticated copy of the foreign judgment certified by a competent authority of the state in which it was given. It also requires an affidavit (a sworn written statement) verifying the facts that establish each of the section 3 conditions.

Regulation 355 adds that the court may require a Hebrew translation. The translation can be certified by an Israeli diplomatic or consular representative serving in the state of judgment, by a diplomatic or consular representative of that state serving in Israel, or in another way the court accepts. Under regulation 356, the respondent may file a response within thirty days of the day a copy of the application was served on him (formally delivered to him), or within any longer period set by the court or the registrar. A respondent who disputes any of the section 3 conditions must attach an affidavit to the response, and a respondent who files no response will not be allowed to oppose the application. Regulation 356A caps the application and the opposition at eight pages each, and the supporting affidavits at six pages.

That page limit changes how the application is prepared. Eight pages leave no space to narrate the entire history of a dispute abroad. They have to be spent on proving the four conditions and on answering, in advance, the grounds of opposition the debtor is likely to raise.

Enforcement is not the only thing available

Not every need calls for enforcement. Sometimes recognition is enough, meaning that the Israeli court accepts the foreign judgment as binding without any collection. That may be so, for instance, where a party wants to rely on a finding made abroad within other proceedings running in Israel. Section 11 provides two separate recognition routes, each with its own conditions.

There is also a route that does not belong to this law at all. A foreign arbitral award, a decision given by arbitrators rather than by a court, is not a foreign judgment. It is confirmed under the law of arbitration and the New York Convention. In an international commercial arbitration that began on or after the commencement of the International Commercial Arbitration Law, 5784-2024, recognition and enforcement of the award are governed by sections 44 and 45 of that law, even where the seat of the arbitration (its formal legal location) is outside Israel. Other arbitrations are governed by the Arbitration Law, 5728-1968 and the Regulations for Implementation of the New York Convention (Foreign Arbitration), 5738-1978. Choosing the wrong route at the outset costs time and money.