Two versions, two tests

The exceptions to the duty to compensate are set out in section 5A(c) of the Sale (Apartments) Law, 5733-1973, and they differ depending on when the contract was signed. A contract signed on or after 7 July 2022 is governed by the current version:

Subsections (a) and (b) shall not apply if one of the following applies to the delay in delivering the apartment: (1) it was caused as a result of an act or omission of the buyer alone; (2) it results from circumstances as described in section 18(a) of the Contracts (Remedies for Breach of Contract) Law, 5731-1970, and the other conditions set out in that section are met with respect to it.

Section 5A(c), Sale (Apartments) Law, 5733-1973, current version

Section 18(a) of the Contracts (Remedies) Law deals with frustration of contract, and its conditions are cumulative:

Where the breach of contract is the result of circumstances which the party in breach, at the time the contract was made, did not know of and was not required to know of, or did not foresee and was not required to foresee, and which he could not have prevented, and performance of the contract under those circumstances is impossible or fundamentally different from what was agreed between the parties, the breach shall not be grounds for enforcement of the contract or for compensation.

Section 18(a), Contracts (Remedies for Breach of Contract) Law, 5731-1970

A contract signed before 7 July 2022 is governed by the earlier version. Under it, the parties could agree in the contract that no compensation would be paid for a delay caused by circumstances beyond the seller's control, where the risk of their occurrence and consequences was not borne by the seller. The Jerusalem District Court stressed that it is not enough for the circumstances to be beyond the seller's control: the seller must also show that the risk of them was not its to bear. The burden of proving this lies on the seller. The court also held that a developer may not widen the contractual exemption beyond the limits of the section, and that events the contract lists as beyond the seller's control must pass through "the filter of the law".

The High Court did not recognise the war as force majeure across the board

Developers asked the Supreme Court, sitting as the High Court of Justice, for general recognition of the "Swords of Iron" war. In HCJ 27036-04-25 a development company's petition to declare the war force majeure was dismissed in limine. The court held that whether the war supports a frustration defence is for the court hearing the claim to decide, on the concrete circumstances of the case, because "not all contracts are born equal".

In HCJ 50085-05-25 the Israel Builders Association mainly sought compensation for developers over the ban on Palestinian workers entering Israel, and also asked that the war be recognised as a frustrating event for the purposes of section 5A(c)(2). The petition was dismissed on several grounds. One of them: the question of late delivery of apartments should first be examined by the trial courts, against the background of concrete cases, particularly as the buyers were not parties to the petition.

So there is no blanket exemption. Each developer has to prove its case in its own file.

What the developer has to prove

The trial courts that have heard these claims have demanded concrete proof. In CC (Haifa District) 58227-12-22 Suleiman v. Vradim Investments and Assets the court held that general assertions are not enough and that the developer had to prove that a specific event caused a specific delay. The court noted that no site diaries, planned schedule, correspondence or minutes of meetings had been produced, and that without them it could not be shown that the developer would have met the deadline but for the events that occurred.

In LCA 39401-09-24 Zilberminz v. Ben David the Supreme Court refused a developer leave to appeal. In that case the Magistrates' Court had reduced compensation by 35%, on an estimated basis, because of COVID-19, and the District Court had reversed the reduction. The Supreme Court noted that a court may award on an estimated basis only after the party bearing the burden has produced all the objective evidence it could produce, and the developer had not done so. The decision concerned COVID-19, but the rule it relies on is a general rule of evidence.

Delays by public authorities do not exempt the developer automatically either. The Nazareth and Jerusalem District Courts held, under the earlier version, that such delays are as a rule part of the risk a developer must allow for when setting its timetable.

Partial exemption, and sometimes full exemption

Even where a court accepted that the war had an effect, it did not necessarily release the developer from all compensation. In Suleiman the court found that the developer had not proved its case as required, yet still granted it, on an estimated basis, a relative exemption because of the combination of two crises, COVID-19 and the war: the 50% statutory uplift was removed for one month, and for buyers who received their apartment after the war broke out, the 25% uplift was also removed for one month. The court relied on an earlier judgment under which the risk may be divided so that the buyer receives compensation equal to the rent only. That earlier judgment stressed that this option arises only where the developer has proved that the delay was caused by circumstances beyond its control. The result in Suleiman is not easy to reconcile with the rule the Supreme Court restated in Zilberminz.

In another case, a small claims court recognised two months of justified delay because of the war.

Some decisions have gone the developers' way. The Be'er Sheva District Court refused leave to appeal to buyers in two cases from Ashkelon. In one, the small claims court had held that the developer should not be charged for the period from the outbreak of the war until 1 February 2024, and the District Court remarked that a state of war imposed suddenly is "force majeure". In the other, the buyer's entire claim for a 48-day delay was dismissed, because the court was persuaded that the delay resulted from circumstances not dependent on the developer.

All these decisions were given by trial courts or on applications for leave to appeal, and none is binding precedent. Suleiman and the two-month small claims case concerned the earlier version of the law, which according to the case law allows the risk to be divided between the parties. Under the current version the test is section 18(a), under which, where its conditions are met, the breach is not grounds for compensation. It should therefore not be assumed that such a division will apply to new contracts too.

Contracts signed after the war began

Section 18(a) deals with circumstances the party in breach did not know of and was not required to foresee when the contract was made, so foreseeability is judged at the date of signing. A developer that signed after 7 October 2023, when the war and its effects on the construction industry were already known, will find it hard to argue that it could not have foreseen them.

What the buyer can do

A buyer who receives notice of a postponement because of the war should first check when the contract was signed, since that determines the test. Keep every notice and all correspondence, and ask the developer to specify the circumstances and how long a delay each of them caused. Be careful about signing a waiver as a condition for receiving the apartment. What happens to such a waiver, under new and old contracts, is explained in the article on compensation.