Two situations in which an order may be issued
Section 20 of the Business Licensing Law, 5728-1968, as worded since Amendment No. 34, enacted in 2018 and in force since 1 January 2019, empowers certain officials to order a business to stop operating, by closing the premises or in any other way that brings about a real cessation. The order is issued in writing, on the basis of an inspector's report, where there is "reasonable ground to assume" that one of two situations exists.
The first situation: a business that requires a licence is operating without a licence, temporary permit or expedited permit, and at the date of the report no more than 18 months have passed since it began operating. Danger to the public is not a condition here, but time matters: after 18 months, this route is closed.
The second situation is not limited in time, but requires more:
A business requiring a licence under this Law is operating without a licence, temporary permit or expedited permit, contrary to their conditions, or contrary to regulations under this Law, and this creates a real danger or a significant concern of harm to the public, having regard to the purposes set out in section 1(a).
Business Licensing Law, 5728-1968, section 20(a)(2) (unofficial translation)
The purposes in section 1(a) include environmental quality and the prevention of nuisances, public order, safety, public health, the aims of planning and building law, and the fire-safety laws.
Who may issue the order
Section 20(c) lists the competent officials:
- The head of the local authority in whose area the business is located, and outside the area of a local authority, a senior Interior Ministry official authorised for the purpose.
- The district police commander.
- A district commander of the National Fire and Rescue Authority.
- A senior official of the Ministry of Environmental Protection authorised for the purpose.
- The head of the National Food Service, the head of the national environmental health system and a district physician at the Ministry of Health, or their deputies.
- The director of veterinary services and the chief labour inspector.
What the Law requires of the order
The Law sets several requirements, and checking them is the starting point for any challenge to the order:
- An inspector's report. For an order in the first situation, the report must be signed and must state the business activity and the finding that 18 months have not passed since it began.
- Consultation with a prosecutor or legal adviser of the licensing authority, or of the approving body on whose behalf the official issuing the order acts. In urgent circumstances the order may be issued first, but it must then be brought to their attention no later than three days after it was issued.
- Contents of the order: the location of the property it applies to, where needed; a description of the facts on which it is based; confirmation that the consultation took place; details of the right to apply for its cancellation; and details of how to contact the official who issued it.
- Service: the order is served in the way a court document is served in civil proceedings.
- For an order in the first situation: it may not be issued if an indictment, or an application for a judicial closure order, has already been filed in respect of the same business.
When the business closes, and for how long
Under an order in the first situation, operations stop within 15 days of the order. The issuing official may order an immediate stop if the activity poses a danger to public health, safety or security, a real public nuisance or real environmental harm. Under an order in the second situation, operations stop immediately, or on a date set in the order that is no later than 15 days.
Under section 21, the order remains in force for 30 days from the day it was issued, unless cancelled earlier. To extend it, the issuing official must apply to the Magistrates' Court or the Local Affairs Court. If an extension application is filed, the order remains in force for seven more days, unless the court decides otherwise. The Law sets no ceiling on the extension period, so the 30 days are not necessarily the end. Whether to extend the order, and for how long, is for the court to decide.
The application to cancel
Under section 22(a), a person who considers themselves harmed by the order may apply to cancel it in the Magistrates' Court or the Local Affairs Court for the area where the business is located. Under section 22(b), the application is heard in the presence of both parties within seven days of filing. The grounds are set by statute:
The court shall not cancel an administrative closure order unless it is proved to it that the business operated lawfully or that the requirements for issuing the order under this Law were not met, or if one of the grounds of administrative law justifying cancellation of the order exists
Business Licensing Law, 5728-1968, section 22(a) (unofficial translation)
These are three separate grounds. First, the business operated lawfully, for example because it held a valid licence or permit. Second, the statutory requirements were not met, such as an inspector's report, legal consultation or, for an order in the first situation, the 18-month limit. Third, a ground of administrative law, such as lack of authority or an unreasonable decision.
Filing the application does not stay the order, unless the court decides otherwise. Anyone who wants the business to keep operating until the hearing must ask for this expressly.
The Law does not mention a hearing before the order is issued. Some decisions of local affairs courts have held, in line with administrative law principles, that absent urgency the business owner should be heard before the order is issued. In a September 2018 decision of the Bnei Brak Local Affairs Court, case 62680-08-18 Danya Cebus v. Mayor of Bnei Brak, the court remarked that the accepted approach is that where there is no real urgency, a closure order should not be issued without a prior hearing. But that order was cancelled mainly because it had no evidential basis, and the decision applied the wording of the section before Amendment No. 34. We have not found a Supreme Court ruling on the question, so it remains open.
These rules apply to an order under the Business Licensing Law. A closure order under another statute is governed by that statute. For example, under section 57 of the National Fire and Rescue Authority Law, 5772-2012, an application to cancel an administrative closure order is filed with the court competent to try the offence the order concerns.
A judicial closure order: a separate route
Amendment 34 added section 22B. Under it, the Magistrates' Court or the Local Affairs Court may, at a prosecutor's request, order a business to stop operating where there is reasonable ground to assume that it is operating without a licence or permit, contrary to their conditions or contrary to regulations. The court must be satisfied that the applicant has prima facie evidence of this. The 18-month limit and the public-danger requirement do not appear in this section, and the order is not conditional on other proceedings under the Law.
In Criminal Miscellaneous Application 5061/24 Afriat Boutique Drinks v. State of Israel (July 2024), business owners argued that the Supreme Court had not yet decided whether it is enough that the business operates without a licence, or whether the court must also consider whether a licence can be obtained in the foreseeable future. Justice Kanfi-Steinitz, sitting alone, dismissed an application for leave to appeal against the District Court's refusal to stay the order pending the appeal. She took no position on the question and, among her reasons, noted that "stopping operations is not an irreversible step".
What happens if the order is not obeyed
Under section 25, a person who does not comply with an administrative closure order is liable to 18 months' imprisonment or a fine, and a company to double the fine. For a continuing offence the court may impose an additional fine for each day. Under section 24, the order may direct the police to enter the premises and remove goods, and to use reasonable force to ensure compliance.
Continuing to operate without a licence also hurts the chances of obtaining relief. In Criminal Leave to Appeal 2150/23 Kuznetsov v. State of Israel (April 2023), Justice Kabub, sitting alone, dismissed an application for leave to appeal concerning a stay of a judicial closure order issued under section 16 of the Law, not an administrative order. Among his reasons, he repeated that the case law has held that, as a rule, judicial relief should not be granted to a person who continues to run a business without a licence.
Businesses selling alcohol
Alongside section 20, section 23 allows a police officer of the rank of superintendent or above to order the immediate closure of a business selling alcoholic drinks, if this is necessary to maintain or restore public order, for a period of up to 30 days. Section 22 applies to such an order, so its cancellation can be sought in the same way.
What to do when an order arrives
- Check under which situation the order was issued. For an order in the first situation, check when the business began operating and whether 18 months had passed by the date of the report.
- Check the order itself: whether it describes the facts, whether it confirms the legal consultation, and who issued it.
- Request the inspector's report on which the order is based.
- File the cancellation application promptly, and where justified, expressly ask in it for a stay until the hearing.
- Advance the licensing process in parallel and document it. A business that keeps operating in breach of the order exposes its owners to criminal liability.