An arbitration award binds like a judgment
Under section 21 of Israel's Arbitration Law, 5728-1968, an award binds the parties and their successors as res judicata, that is, as a final decision that cannot be litigated again. This is subject to sections 24 to 28 of the Law, and to any different intention implied by the arbitration agreement. To enforce the award, the winning party asks the court to confirm it. Under section 23(a), a confirmed award has the same effect as a court judgment for all purposes except appeal.
The losing party may apply to have the award set aside. But an application to set aside is not an appeal, and it is limited to the grounds in the Law.
This article deals with domestic arbitration. Since 2024, international commercial arbitration seated in Israel has been governed by a separate statute, the International Commercial Arbitration Law, 5784-2024; under its section 3, the Arbitration Law does not apply to it. The grounds and time limits there are different.
The court does not sit on appeal from the arbitrator
The Supreme Court has restated this principle in Leave for Civil Appeal 4273/19 M.B. Glatt Of v. Birkat Haaretz (August 2019):
The grounds in section 24 of the Law concern mainly claims relating to the propriety of the arbitration proceedings, and they cannot be used to raise claims about errors in the substance of the arbitrator's decision.
Leave for Civil Appeal 4273/19 M.B. Glatt Of Lemehadrin Ltd. v. Birkat Haaretz Ltd. (4.8.2019), para. 15 (unofficial translation)
In Leave for Civil Appeal 8218/22 Bit Up Digital v. Steiner (December 2022) the Supreme Court said that it is not the court's job to sit as an appeal court over an arbitrator's decisions. An argument that the arbitrator got the facts wrong, believed the wrong witness or misread the contract is therefore not, by itself, enough to set the award aside. The parties chose an arbitrator instead of a court, and this is the price of that choice.
The ten grounds for setting an award aside
Section 24 lists the grounds on which the court may set aside an award in whole or in part, complete it, correct it or send it back to the arbitrator:
- There was no valid arbitration agreement.
- The arbitrator was not properly appointed.
- The arbitrator acted without authority or exceeded the powers given in the arbitration agreement.
- A party was not given a proper opportunity to put its case or present its evidence.
- The arbitrator did not decide one of the matters submitted to him.
- The arbitrator gave no reasons although he was required to. Since 2008 the default rule in the Law is that an award must be reasoned, unless the parties agreed otherwise.
- The parties agreed that the arbitrator would decide according to law, and he did not.
- The award was given after the time for giving it had expired.
- The content of the award is contrary to public policy.
- There is a ground on which a court would set aside a final judgment no longer open to appeal.
Public policy is the odd one out, because it concerns the content of the award rather than the process. In Glatt Of the Supreme Court said it is reserved for rare cases and exceptional circumstances. There, the arbitrators, three rabbis sitting in a rabbinical tribunal for monetary disputes, had included in an interim award a "sanction" against a party that applied to the courts. The Supreme Court held that an award which blocks a party from going to court, or makes it substantially harder, is contrary to public policy, and it struck out the sanction clause.
Complaints about the arbitrator's conduct, as opposed to the content of the award, belong as a rule in an application to remove him under section 11 of the Law. According to the same judgment, the proper course is to make that application before the award is given. After the award, such complaints can only support a ground for setting aside under section 24.
Even where a ground exists, the award is not always set aside
Under section 26(a), the court may dismiss an application to set aside even where one of the grounds is made out, if it considers that no miscarriage of justice was caused. Under section 26(b), it will not set aside the whole award if it can set aside only part of it, complete it, correct it or send it back. In Glatt Of, for example, the court struck out only the sanction clause and left the awards in place, partly because the sanction was never actually applied and no miscarriage of justice resulted.
A complaint of delay has its own condition. Under section 26(c), a party may not argue that the award was given late unless it reserved that right in a written notice to the arbitrator before the award was made.
45 days to apply
Section 27(a) sets the deadline:
The court shall not entertain an application to set aside filed more than forty-five days after the award was given, if it was given in the applicant's presence, or after the day on which a copy of the award was delivered to the applicant by the arbitrator or by a party, if it was given in his absence; the court may extend that period, even after it has expired, for special reasons to be recorded, and in any case where an application to confirm a foreign arbitral award has been filed.
Arbitration Law, 5728-1968, section 27(a) (unofficial translation)
This deadline matters more than it seems. Under section 23(b), the court will hear an objection to confirmation of an award only by way of an application to set it aside, or in an appeal under section 29B where the parties agreed to one. A party who did not apply in time, and did not obtain an extension for special reasons, will find it very hard to object when the other side asks for confirmation. And under section 27(c), once the award has been confirmed the court will not hear an application to set it aside, except one based on the last ground on the list, the one on which even a final judgment can be set aside (section 27(d)).
The period can also be shorter. If the other side applies to confirm the award, regulation 10 of the Arbitration Procedure Regulations, 5729-1968, allows an objection by way of an application to set aside within 15 days of service of the notice of that application, provided it is not later than the section 27 deadline. If no objection is filed, the court or the registrar will confirm the award without hearing the parties. Assuming you always have 45 days is therefore risky.
There are some exceptions to the 45-day rule. If a party asked the arbitrator to correct a clerical or arithmetical error, or to add a provision on interest or costs (section 22), the 45 days run from the day the arbitrator decided, or should have decided, that request. For an application based on the last ground on the list, the period runs from the day the facts on which it rests came to light. And the deadline does not apply to a claim that there was no valid arbitration agreement (section 27(b) and (d)).
An appeal against an award: only by agreement
According to the Supreme Court in Leave for Civil Appeal 1242/15 M. Adler Engineering v. Katan (April 2016), until the Arbitration Law was amended in 2008 judicial review of awards was limited almost entirely to the grounds for setting aside, and in practice there was no other way to challenge mistakes in the arbitrator's decision. The amendment added two appeal routes. Both apply only if the parties choose them.
Appeal to another arbitrator (section 21A). The parties may agree that the award can be appealed to a further arbitrator. The arbitrator must then give reasons. On the other hand, the final award can be challenged only on two grounds, public policy and the ground on which a final judgment can be set aside, and no application for leave to appeal to the court is possible. In Bit Up the District Court dismissed an application to set aside an appeal award because it was not based on either of those grounds, and the Supreme Court saw no reason to intervene.
Appeal to the court with leave (section 29B). Parties who agreed that the arbitrator would decide according to law may also agree that the award can be appealed to the court, with leave. The hearings must then be recorded and the award reasoned. In Adler Engineering the Supreme Court held that leave will be granted only where three conditions are all met: the error is fundamental, it is an error in applying the law, and it is capable of causing a miscarriage of justice. The court noted that errors in findings of fact or in awards of costs appear to be far from that standard. At the same time it stressed that the applicant must not face an obstacle so high that the appeal ceases to be a practical option. It also said, obiter, that a party seeking leave under section 29B should include in the same application, as alternative arguments, all its grounds for setting the award aside under section 24.
Further appeal
An application to set aside or confirm an award is heard by the court that would have jurisdiction over the dispute itself, so sometimes the Magistrates' Court and sometimes the District Court. Leave to appeal against its judgment may be sought from the court above. In the Supreme Court, in Bit Up, the court repeated that leave to appeal in arbitration matters is granted only in exceptional cases raising a question of principle or public importance beyond the parties' own dispute, or where intervention is needed for reasons of justice and to prevent a miscarriage of justice. In the same case it remarked, obiter, that a fresh application to set aside on new grounds, a kind of "second attempt", cannot be accepted. It is wise, then, to put every ground into the first application.
Practical steps
- Decide on an appeal route when drafting the arbitration agreement. Once the dispute has broken out such agreement is hard to reach, and without it review of the award is limited to the grounds for setting aside.
- Note the date the award was given or a copy was received, and count 45 days from it. If the other side has applied to confirm the award, check at once whether the deadline has shrunk to 15 days.
- If the arbitrator appears to be deciding a matter that was not submitted to him, object in writing during the arbitration.
- Take a clerical or arithmetical error, or a missing provision on interest or costs, to the arbitrator first, under section 22. A request on interest or costs must be made within 30 days.
- If the arbitration runs past its time limit, send the arbitrator written notice reserving the right to raise the point, before the award is given.
- Raise complaints about the arbitrator's conduct during the arbitration, in an application to remove him, rather than saving them for after the award.