Which decisions are challenged by administrative petition

The Court for Administrative Affairs hears petitions against decisions of authorities, but not every decision. Under section 5 of Israel's Administrative Affairs Courts Law, 5760-2000, it hears petitions against a decision of an authority or body listed in the First Schedule to the Law, on a matter listed in that Schedule.

The Schedule covers many fields, among them planning and building under the Planning and Building Law (except supervision, enforcement and penalties, decisions on national and district outline plans, and decisions of the Minister of the Interior or the Minister of Finance), business licensing, such as granting, revoking or setting conditions for a business licence, and tenders of local authorities and of bodies required to hold tenders under the Mandatory Tenders Law. The list is amended from time to time. A petition on a matter not in it is outside the court's jurisdiction under section 5(1), unless another statute confers jurisdiction, so the first step is to check which court to go to. The petition itself must state the source of jurisdiction and the relevant item in the Schedule (regulation 5(b)(3a) of the procedure regulations).

45 days, and sometimes less

Regulation 3 of the Administrative Affairs Courts (Procedure) Regulations, 5761-2000, sets the deadline:

Where no time has been so set, the petition shall be filed without delay, according to the circumstances, and no later than forty-five days from the day the decision was duly published, or from the day the petitioner received notice of it, or from the day it became known to the petitioner, whichever is earliest.

Administrative Affairs Courts (Procedure) Regulations, 5761-2000, regulation 3(b) (unofficial translation)

Three points in this regulation matter. First, the 45 days apply only where the law has not set a different time. Some statutes set their own deadline or procedure. With building permits, for instance, a person whose objection was rejected or whose permit application was refused may appeal to the appeals committee within 30 days of being served with the decision (section 152 of the Planning and Building Law), and the Supreme Court has described that appeal as the "proper course" in such situations. Second, time runs from the earliest of three events: due publication of the decision, receipt of notice of it, or the day the petitioner learned of it. Someone who waited for a formal letter after already knowing of the decision may find that time started earlier. Third, the regulation requires filing "without delay", and the 45 days are the outer limit, not the recommended time.

Under regulation 3(c), the court may extend the deadline if it sees justification, after giving the respondents an opportunity to respond. In Leave for Administrative Appeal 3802/16 Arlet Initiatives v. Southern District Appeals Committee the Supreme Court noted that such a request is assessed under the general doctrine of delay described below. Anyone seeking an extension must explain the delay.

Prior application to the authority

Before filing a petition, the petitioner writes to the authority, sets out the arguments and asks it to change the decision. Under regulation 5(b)(6), that correspondence is attached to the petition, and if there was no such approach, the petition must explain why. In the Supreme Court, in passing in a case about an administrative class action, the prior application was described as the requirement usually accepted as part of exhausting remedies before filing an administrative petition (Administrative Appeal 7639/20 Ezer v. Rehovot Municipality). The High Court of Justice has added that the approach must give the authority sufficient time to consider the arguments and reply, and that it is not a formal or technical condition but a substantive threshold requirement.

This creates a tension. The approach takes time, and the 45 days keep running. The regulations do not say that writing to the authority stops the clock, and the Supreme Court has rejected the argument that waiting for the authority's reply justifies a late filing. In Administrative Appeal 7208/19 HaMerkaz HeHadash v. Ramat HaSharon Municipality a petition was filed about nine months after the payment demand, after the company had waited "in good faith" for the municipality's answer. The court held that the regulations bind all petitioners, including those acting in good faith, and dismissed the petition in limine. It noted that the municipality had not responded properly, but said that this failure did not justify the delay. The letter to the authority should therefore go out in the first few days after learning of the decision, with a reasonable date for a reply, so that there is time to prepare a petition if the answer is negative or never comes.

Delay: even a timely petition may be dismissed

Regulation 4 adds that the court may dismiss a petition "if it considers that in the circumstances there was delay in filing it, even if it was filed within one of the times under regulation 3". Meeting the 45 days is therefore no guarantee.

The case law looks at three elements of delay. In Administrative Appeal 6881/07 Berger v. Emek Hefer Regional Council the Supreme Court described them as follows: subjective delay, meaning whether the petitioner's conduct shows that he gave up his rights; objective delay, meaning whether the delay harmed protected interests of the authority or of third parties, for example someone who acted on the decision; and on the other side, whether refusing to hear the petition would seriously harm the rule of law.

Objective delay is sometimes decisive even where the petitioner is blameless. In Administrative Appeal 867/11 Tel Aviv-Yafo Municipality v. I.B.C. the Supreme Court wrote that a petition may be dismissed for delay even if the petitioner's conduct is entirely free of fault, where the passage of time itself caused considerable harm. In planning matters, for instance, once the developer has started building under a permit, every week of waiting may change the picture.

The petition does not stop the decision

Under regulation 42, filing a petition does not in itself stay the implementation of the decision. If the decision is about to be carried out, for example revoking a licence or signing a contract with the winner of a tender, the petitioner must ask the court for an interim order. Under regulation 9, that application is filed separately from the petition, when the petition is filed or later.

Practical steps

  • Note the day you learned of the decision, even if you have not yet received it in writing. Time may start running from that day.
  • Check whether the decision falls within the First Schedule to the Law, and whether a special statute sets a different deadline or forum for it.
  • Write to the authority within a few days, setting out your main arguments and asking for a reply by a reasonable date.
  • Do not wait for a reply until day 45. If the answer is slow in coming, file the petition, or at least an application to extend time, before the deadline passes.
  • If the decision is about to be carried out, file an application for an interim order together with the petition.