A new date is allowed; a disguised exemption is not
In LCA 6605/15 Shemesh v. Space Construction and Development, the Supreme Court observed that, on the face of it, the very possibility of setting a new delivery date does not conflict with the Sale (Apartments) Law, 5733-1973, since the delay is then counted from the new agreed date. A clause releasing the developer from the duty to compensate, beyond what the law itself allows, is a different matter: section 5A of the law is a mandatory provision.
In Shemesh the contract provided that ordering changes would postpone delivery "for the period in which the said additions and changes are carried out, and at least for a period of 60 days". The Supreme Court held that such a broad provision, which lets the developer postpone delivery without clearly setting a new date, is not an agreement on a new date but an exemption clause. It added that the buyer cannot tell from it when the apartment will be handed over, and so cannot plan ahead.
The court also relied on the rule of interpretation against the drafter in section 25(b1) of the Contracts (General Part) Law, 5733-1973. Where a contract can be read in more than one way and one party had the upper hand in shaping its terms, the reading against that party is preferred to the reading in its favour. Here that party was the developer.
Postponement for a defined period
LCA 3088/20 Peled v. Azorim Building (1965) concerned a change agreement that postponed delivery "for a period of up to 13 weeks". The Supreme Court (Justice N. Sohlberg) refused the buyers leave to appeal, noting that the period was limited and defined:
From the apartment buyer's point of view, there is a concrete and clear delivery date, before which the developer must complete the work.
LCA 3088/20 Peled v. Azorim Building (1965) Ltd (25.10.2020)
The distinction between the two decisions: a postponement to a date that can be worked out in advance can be a legitimate agreement on a new date. An open-ended postponement, whose length is up to the developer, is an exemption from compensation in another guise. In Shemesh the court also noted that a later agreement on a new date may result from negotiation between the parties, provided it did not stem from a unilateral initiative of the developer that left the buyer no choice.
What if the postponement is too long for the change
In Shemesh the Supreme Court noted that setting a new date may raise further questions where the date bears no reasonable relation to the scope of the change, but it did not decide them.
The Jerusalem District Court, in the judgment that was the subject of Peled, asked whether the period set flowed reasonably from carrying out the changes, and held that the burden of proving it was unreasonable lies on the buyer. The buyers in that case filed no expert opinion and did not even produce the form listing the changes they had ordered, so their argument was rejected and compensation was calculated from the new date. The Magistrates' Court in the same case had put the burden on the developer, and the District Court reversed that finding. The Supreme Court did not intervene: it noted that the relationship between the scope of the changes and the length of the postponement was not up for decision, and that the finding, including on the burden of proof, did not justify intervention at a third tier.
What to check before ordering changes
- Whether the change agreement sets a defined period of postponement or leaves its length open.
- Whether the length of the postponement is reasonable for the change itself. Moving an electrical point is not the same as moving a wall.
- Keep a copy of the detailed change form and of the correspondence with the developer. In Peled the District Court put the burden of proving that the postponement was too long on the buyers, and their argument failed because they brought no evidence.
- What the new delivery date is once all the changes are taken together. The delay is counted from that date.