Compensation without proof of loss

Section 5A of the Sale (Apartments) Law, 5733-1973 sets up a special compensation scheme for people who buy a new apartment from a developer. If the apartment is not delivered on time, the buyer does not have to prove what the delay cost. Compensation is based on the rent for a similar apartment of similar size and location, for each month of delay.

If the seller has not placed the apartment at the buyer's disposal after one month has passed from the end of the date fixed for this in the sale contract (in this section, the contractual date), the buyer is entitled to compensation, without proof of damage, in the amount set out below, for each month or part of a month from the end of one month after the contractual date until the apartment is placed at the buyer's disposal, or to compensation in the amount agreed in the sale contract for late delivery of the apartment, whichever is higher:

Section 5A(a), Sale (Apartments) Law, 5733-1973, current version

The buyer receives either the statutory compensation or the compensation set in the contract, whichever is higher. It is paid at the end of each month for that month, not at the end of the delay.

In LCA 6605/15 Shemesh v. Space Construction and Development, the Supreme Court held that section 5A is a mandatory provision: a contract cannot reduce it. Section 7A(a) of the law provides that its provisions cannot be varied by agreement except in favour of the buyer.

Which version applies depends on when the contract was signed

Section 5A was added to the law by Amendment No. 5 in 2011 and amended in 2022 by Amendment No. 9. Section 11(d) provides that Amendment No. 9 does not apply to an apartment whose sale contract was made before it came into force, and that such contracts remain governed by the earlier version. Amendment No. 9 came into force on 7 July 2022.

This is not a technicality. Building projects often take several years, so contracts signed before July 2022 still come before the courts. The two versions differ both in the date from which compensation runs and in the amount.

Contracts signed on or after 7 July 2022

Under the current version the right to compensation arises once one month has passed from the contractual date, and compensation is calculated from the end of that month. The first month of delay is not compensated. From there compensation rises in three steps:

  • From the end of one month after the contractual date until the end of four months after it: an amount equal to the rent.
  • From five months after the contractual date until the end of ten months after it: the rent multiplied by 1.25.
  • From 11 months after the contractual date onwards: the rent multiplied by 1.5.

Amendment No. 9 also added section 5C, which limits indexation. The parties may agree that up to half of each payment is linked to the construction inputs index, provided that 20% of the contract price, paid when the contract is made or before any other payment, is not linked. The linkage runs at the latest until the delivery date fixed in the contract. The developer therefore does not collect indexation for the period of delay. The exception is a delay that falls within one of the situations in section 5A(c).

Contracts signed before 7 July 2022

These contracts are governed by the earlier version, as set out in the Shemesh case:

  • The right to compensation arises once 60 days have passed from the contractual date, and compensation is then calculated from the contractual date itself, so the first 60 days are compensated too.
  • From the contractual date until the end of eight months after it: the rent multiplied by 1.5.
  • From nine months after the contractual date onwards: the rent multiplied by 1.25.
  • Compensation for the first 60 days is paid at the end of those 60 days.

Which version is better for the buyer depends on the length of the delay. For a delay of up to 60 days the earlier version gives no compensation at all, while the current version gives compensation from the end of the first month. For a longer delay the earlier version is more generous in the first months, because compensation runs from the contractual date itself and the rent is multiplied by 1.5.

In Shemesh the Supreme Court noted that another clause in the same contract, stating that a delay of up to 60 days "for any reason whatsoever" would not entitle the buyer to compensation, conflicted with the statutory right to compensation for the first sixty days of delay. Section 5A does not apply at all to an apartment whose sale contract was made before Amendment No. 5 came into force in 2011, nor to an apartment in a building completed before then.

Proving the rent

The law refers to the rent for a similar apartment of similar size and location but does not name a figure, so the amount has to be proved. In these claims the parties usually file valuers' opinions. Where the opinions conflict, the court may appoint a valuer of its own. That is what happened in Peled, where the Jerusalem District Court declined to interfere with a finding based on the opinion of the valuer appointed by the Magistrates' Court, and in cases heard by the Herzliya and Tel Aviv Magistrates' Courts.

Waiving compensation to get the keys

Some developers ask buyers to sign a waiver of delay claims as a condition for handing over the apartment. For contracts signed on or after 7 July 2022, the law deals with this directly:

Without derogating from subsection (a), a waiver, including in writing, of rights of the buyer or sub-purchaser in connection with late delivery under section 5A or with a non-conformity or fundamental non-conformity, which is a condition for transferring rights from a buyer to a sub-purchaser, for carrying out repairs in the apartment or for placing the apartment at the buyer's disposal, is void.

Section 7A(b), Sale (Apartments) Law, 5733-1973, as amended by Amendment No. 9

The reference to late delivery was added to section 7A(b) by Amendment No. 9, so under the transitional provision it does not apply to older contracts. Even for those contracts, courts have repeatedly held, on the basis of section 7A(a), that a waiver of compensation signed as part of receiving the apartment has no effect.

Not every later agreement is void, however. The Herzliya Magistrates' Court remarked, obiter, that such an arrangement may stand if it reflects a reasonable compromise of a genuine dispute, and that it is expected to be made after the apartment has been handed over, when buyers are aware of their rights. It added that it was prepared to assume that the burden of showing this lies on the seller. In another case waivers were upheld because, in return, the developer wrote off debts the buyers owed it. These are first-instance decisions, and they show that the court looks at the circumstances in which the waiver was signed.

When the developer is exempt

Under the current version, compensation is not payable in two situations only: where the delay was caused solely by an act or omission of the buyer, or where the conditions of section 18(a) of the Contracts (Remedies for Breach of Contract) Law, 5731-1970, which deals with frustration, are met. Under the earlier version the parties could agree in the contract on an exemption for delay caused by circumstances beyond the seller's control, where the risk of their occurrence and consequences was not borne by the seller. Claims of war and "force majeure", and the way courts examine them, are covered in a separate article.