Background
The buyers bought a new cottage from the company under a contract signed in July 2019. It was handed over in April 2020. Two and a half weeks later they sent the company a report by their own engineer, who put the cost of repairing the defects at about ILS 65,000 including VAT.
In June 2020, two months after delivery, they sued for ILS 210,000, claiming compensation for construction defects, late delivery, alternative housing during the repairs, and distress. The claim was filed before the inspection period had ended. That period begins on delivery, and during it the seller is liable for any defect that comes to light in the apartment, unless it proves that the buyer caused it.
The company's position
The company argued that the buyers had prevented it from inspecting the house and repairing the defects it was responsible for, despite its repeated requests. Its statement of defence insisted on its right to repair. In closing submissions it asked the court to strike out the claim and order the company to carry out the repairs. In the alternative, it asked that the repair cost set by the court-appointed expert be reduced by half, since according to the expert that was what repairs by the company would cost.
It also argued that the buyers had signed four change requests, in each of which they agreed to postpone the delivery date by 30 days, and that together with the 60-day grace period in the contract there had been no delay.
What the court held on the repairs
The court accepted the company's position on this point. In the passage below, the plaintiffs are the buyers and the defendant is the company.
On the evidence, I have concluded that the plaintiffs were in a hurry to file the claim, and that before filing it (about two months after the apartment was handed over to them, and before the inspection period had ended) the plaintiffs did not give the defendant a fair opportunity to carry out repairs in the apartment, despite the defendant's requests and its willingness to inspect the apartment and carry out the repairs for which it was responsible.
Tel Aviv-Jaffa Magistrates' Court, judgment of 2023, para. 26 (unofficial translation)
The finding rested on the company's letters, to which the buyers produced no reply, on recorded conversations, and on affidavits of the company's staff that were not contradicted. They showed that the buyers would not let the company's workers into the house and allowed them to work only in the yard, and that on some occasions they announced they had already done the repairs themselves. The buyer herself testified that once they had gone to a lawyer intending to sue, "we no longer let them in".
The court rejected the buyers' claim that they had lost trust in the company because of the delivery date and the condition of the house. The delivery protocol listed minor defects, and the WhatsApp messages the parties exchanged before delivery did not fit that claim.
The buyers also argued that the company had lost its right to repair by rejecting their expert's report in its defence. The court rejected that argument too. It found that the dispute between the experts was mainly about the pricing of the repairs, not about whether most of the defects existed, and that the company had insisted on its right to repair throughout the proceedings.
The effect on compensation
Under section 4B(a) of the Sale (Apartments) Law, 5733-1973, where a repairable defect is discovered, the buyer must give the seller a fair opportunity to repair it, and the seller must repair it within a reasonable time. The court relied on Supreme Court case law under which, as a rule, a buyer who did not let the seller repair keeps the right to compensation, but the compensation is reduced to what the repair would have cost the seller had it done the work itself.
The court-appointed expert found that repairs by casual contractors would cost 30% more than his estimate, and repairs by the company half of it. In their closing submissions the buyers asked for about ILS 63,000, the cost of repair by a casual contractor.
The court held that the company had not lost its right to repair. It did not strike out the claim or order the company to carry out the repairs. Instead it held that the cost of repair should be reduced by 50%, and awarded the buyers about ILS 31,500 including VAT for the repairs, half of what they had asked for.
For distress the court awarded ILS 3,000. The buyers had claimed at least ILS 30,000 under this head, which also covered their trouble, lost working days and payments to lawyers and experts. The court noted that a substantial part of the defects called for spot repairs that did not seriously disrupt the buyers' daily lives, and that no actual loss of working days had been proved.
It added that suing without giving the seller a chance to repair wastes court time and puts the seller to expense, and that such conduct should not be encouraged. It did not deny compensation altogether, but limited it mainly to the inconvenience and trouble of the repair period. The claim for alternative housing failed, because the expert had not found that it would be needed, and the buyers dropped it in their closing submissions.
Late delivery
The buyers claimed an eight-month delay and ILS 45,000 for it. The court held that the change requests justified postponing delivery to 1 March 2020, as the buyer herself had agreed before suing. It noted that the statement of claim did not disclose that the buyers had signed the change requests.
Other arguments of the company on this issue were rejected. The four requests did not automatically extend the date by 120 days, and the grace period in the contract could not be added to the postponement. That left a delay of a month and a half.
No compensation was awarded for that delay either. Section 5A of the Sale (Apartments) Law entitles a buyer to compensation for late delivery without proof of damage, calculated from the rent of a similar apartment of similar size and location. Relying on a judgment of the Beersheba District Court, the court held that the amount of that rent must be proved by evidence. Apart from the buyer's own testimony there was none, such as a valuer's opinion or lease agreements.
Contracts signed before 7 July 2022 are governed by an earlier version of section 5A, under which the right to compensation arises only if the apartment is not delivered within 60 days of the contractual date. The delay in this case was shorter than that, and the court did not need to address the point.
The outcome
The company was ordered to pay about ILS 39,000 plus linkage differentials and interest, against a claim of ILS 210,000. The sum comprises about ILS 31,500 for repairs, ILS 3,000 for distress and about ILS 4,700, the buyers' share of the court expert's fee.
The company was also ordered to pay 18.5% of the court fee, being the ratio of the award to the amount claimed, and legal costs of ILS 6,000. In setting the costs the court also took into account that the buyers had rushed to sue before giving the company an opportunity to repair. It noted that the settlement proposals put forward during the proceedings had been higher than its award, but they had not been agreed by both parties.
What the case shows
Here, filing the claim did not take away the company's right to repair. The buyers had not given it a fair opportunity to repair beforehand, and the company insisted on its right throughout the proceedings. Its dispute with the buyers' expert was mainly about pricing, not about whether most of the defects existed. The court relied on the company's letters, on recorded conversations and on its impression of the witnesses.
A developer that intends to insist on its right to repair should record every request and every refusal, and raise the right to repair in its statement of defence. For buyers, the case shows the cost of going to court too early. A buyer who sues over defects without giving the seller a fair opportunity to repair risks reduced compensation (in this case, half of what the buyers claimed for repairs) and a small award for distress.