Background
The buyers of an apartment sued the company that sold it to them, alleging serious defects. The claim came to about ILS 503,000: about ILS 163,000 for repairs, ILS 275,000 for loss of value, ILS 15,000 for moving out during the works and ILS 50,000 for distress.
The buyers' engineer put the defects at about ILS 82,000 including VAT, noting that if a casual contractor did the work the cost could double. The developer's expert put them at about ILS 13,000.
What the court expert found
With the parties' consent, the court appointed an expert who is both an engineer and a valuer. He put the repairs at ILS 60,000 plus VAT, adding 20% to 50% if a casual contractor did the work. On loss of value he found: "no loss of value was found". The defect, he said, could be fixed, and if the contractor failed to fix it after a reasonable and serious effort would it be right to consider loss of value.
Repairs in kind
The parties agreed that the developer would carry out the repairs itself, under the expert's supervision. The repairs were done, and a procedural arrangement given the force of a court decision recorded that the developer had repaired all the defects and the buyers had no further claims about them. That took both the claim for the cost of repairs and the loss-of-value claim off the table. Only costs and distress were left to decide.
Costs and distress
The buyers asked, among other things, for ILS 50,000 for distress, reimbursement of the court fee and the expert reports, compensation for lost working days, and legal fees of 15% to 20% of the award. The developer argued that nothing should be awarded, because the buyers had not sent it their report or given it a chance to repair before suing.
The court awarded the buyers about ILS 9,400 in costs, ILS 7,500 for distress and ILS 14,000 in legal fees. It did not reimburse the valuer's report, because the court expert had not accepted the loss-of-value claim and the repairs had in fact been done, and it held that lost working days had not been proved. It set the court-fee reimbursement at ILS 2,000, taking into account, among other things, the expert's estimate of the cost of repairs.
The court did not accept the developer's position that nothing should be awarded. It did not decide whether the developer had been given a chance to repair before the claim, but held that the buyers could not be said to have refused cooperation, because the developer had disputed their position, which proved largely justified. In assessing distress it also took into account that the buyers had lived with the defects from delivery in 2020 until 2024.
The outcome
A claim of about ILS 503,000 ended with the developer repairing the defects itself and being ordered to pay the buyers about ILS 16,900 plus linkage differentials and interest, together with ILS 14,000 in legal fees. The loss-of-value claim, the largest item, yielded the buyers nothing.
What the case shows
Here, repairs in kind under the supervision of the court expert made most of the claim redundant. The expert himself tied the question of loss of value to whether the defect would be fixed, and once it was fixed the claim lost its basis. Even so, when defects are repaired the court may still award the buyers costs and compensation for distress, taking into account how long they lived with the defects.