Background

From 2016 a lawyer represented all five siblings jointly in proceedings before the Family Court and the Rabbinical Court. All the siblings signed powers of attorney in her favour.

In 2018 two of the sisters brought a money claim against their brother. The same lawyer announced that she would represent him. Adv. Grunis, counsel for the sisters, objected at once on grounds of conflict of interest, but she took on the case.

The Ethics Committee

The lawyer applied to the Israel Bar's Ethics Committee, and Adv. Grunis submitted the sisters' response. The committee recommended that she not represent the brother. In its view, the dispute turned mainly on how the estate had been divided and on the heirs' agreements, which had been settled during the joint representation, so this was the same matter under rule 16(a) of the Rules of Professional Ethics.

A lawyer shall not act against a client (1) in a matter, or in connection with a matter, which he handled for that client; (2) in a matter to which information he received from that client, or on his behalf, has a real connection.

Israel Bar Rules (Professional Ethics), 5746-1986, rule 16(a) (unofficial translation)

The lawyer continued to act for the brother, and a few days after the committee's recommendation the sisters made an urgent application to the court to disqualify her. A few days later the lawyer told the committee that its recommendation was wrong and that she intended to go on acting.

The decision

The court held that ethics questions are normally a matter for the Bar's own bodies. It nevertheless has power to address them under its general authority in section 75 of the Courts Law, where the facts carry a potential for harm to the parties' rights and to the fairness of the proceedings.

On the merits, the court held that since the lawyer had represented all the parties, it was "logical and reasonable" that she had been exposed to substantial information from all of them, including information covered by lawyer-client privilege. She was now acting against former clients, on a subject similar to the one in which she had represented them all, which, the court said, "raises an inherent difficulty". The court relied on Supreme Court case law on the importance of rule 16, and on an Ethics Committee decision that, in principle, the rule applies to every lawyer in the office.

The court granted the application. It disqualified the lawyer and anyone in her office from acting for the brother, and ordered the brother to pay the sisters ILS 7,500 in costs and legal fees.

What the case shows

Under rule 16(a), a lawyer may not act against a client in a matter he handled for that client, or in a matter to which information received from that client has a real connection. Here Adv. Grunis objected to the representation in the very conversation in which the lawyer announced it, and put the sisters' position to the Ethics Committee. When the lawyer carried on after the committee's recommendation, he made an urgent application to the court. The application was granted, and the lawyer who used to represent the sisters may not act for their brother in these proceedings.