Background
A company ordered sea freight of a container from England, via the Netherlands, to Israel from an international freight forwarder, and did not pay for it. The container reached Israel in March 2019 and stayed in Ashdod port. The forwarder sued for payment.
The customer argued that it owed nothing. It said the forwarder had "simply disappeared with the equipment", that the container held equipment worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, and that it had suffered damage of hundreds of thousands of shekels. It announced a claim of more than USD 300,000 and, in the alternative, sought to set its damage off against the claim.
The Magistrates' Court judgment
The claim was heard under the fast-track procedure. The court heard evidence, preferred the testimony of the forwarder's witness to that of the customer's, and held that there was an agreement between the parties and that the amount claimed was the agreed price. At the outset of its judgment the court described the case as a refusal to pay "that has no basis whatsoever", and the whole proceeding as "nothing but an attempt to put off the inevitable" on the customer's part.
The court rejected the argument that payment was due only once the goods arrived "door to door", at the customer's warehouse. It held that paying the forwarder was a condition for releasing the container from the port, as the invoice also showed: "sea shipment from England via the Netherlands, payment in advance". It further held that the customer signed the bill of lading, without which the customs broker could not release the container, only in July 2019, although it had been told by email in March that it needed to sign. Responsibility for the container remaining in the port therefore lay with the customer.
The set-off defence also failed. Once the customer was found responsible for the container remaining in the port, it had no basis. The court added that the alleged damage had not been substantiated: the customer itself had declared the goods to customs at about EUR 13,000, and produced no evidence of the hundreds of thousands of dollars it claimed. In the court's words, it had tried to meet the claim "by inflating figures and alleging damage dozens of times greater, without any basis".
The claim was upheld in full. The customer was ordered to pay about ILS 43,000 plus linkage differentials and interest, costs of ILS 5,000, the court fee and legal fees of ILS 20,000. The court awarded the forwarder its actual costs, because the customer had dragged it into full proceedings and defended with arguments that turned out to have no basis at all.
The appeal
The customer appealed to the District Court, challenging the findings of fact and the assessment of the witnesses. The District Court decided the appeal on the written material, without an oral hearing, and dismissed it.
As a rule, an appellate court interferes with findings of fact and credibility only in exceptional cases, which are certainly not present here.
Tel Aviv-Jaffa District Court, judgment of 2021, para. 7 (unofficial translation)
The court noted that the Magistrates' Court judgment consisted entirely of findings of fact and credibility, made by a court that heard the witnesses and formed a direct impression of them. Nor did it interfere with the costs: the Magistrates' Court had indeed awarded costs at the high end, but had, it said, given proper reasons for doing so. On appeal the customer was ordered to pay reduced costs and legal fees totalling ILS 8,000, to be paid to the forwarder out of the security it had deposited.
What the case shows
Here the court also relied on the documents: an invoice requiring payment in advance, and an email about the need to sign the bill of lading. Against them, an unsupported claim of damage running to hundreds of thousands was not enough to set off the debt. And as the District Court pointed out, an appellate court will, as a rule, interfere with findings of fact and credibility only in exceptional cases.